Of all the meetings on a leader’s calendar, 1:1s can be the most tempting to skip. They take up time, you just saw your direct report in five other meetings, and you don’t have anything pressing to discuss… Especially when we start to feel the end of year crunch -- budget meetings, Q4 planning, reviews, and more -- the temptation to cancel can be hard to resist.
Why keep the 1:1?
It’s not fully on you
Research has shown that “1:1 ratings were highest when the agenda was created jointly or by the direct [report] only, and lowest when the agenda was created solely by the manager” (Rogelberg, Glad We Met)
This means, while you do need to create the space, you do not have to draft the whole agenda yourself. This makes keeping the meeting on your calendar a lighter lift than you think.
I recommend sharing a template with clear sections and providing instructions for how to fill it out and by when (example). Note that Rogelberg's research found an agenda template matters less than the principles behind it, so feel free to adapt. Find more structure ideas in the links section below.
1:1s prevent surprises, in both directions
While, a 1:1 should not be a status meeting, it should give your direct report a private place to flag blockers, ask for help, and work through issues before they become big problems. Skipping 1:1s may mean unwelcome surprises for you later.
Performance reviews should not be the first time a direct report hears feedback. Your 1:1 meetings give you a private opportunity to share observations, ask questions, and course-correct well beforehand, so they aren't surprised come review time.
Built-in professional development
The 1:1 meeting is one of the best places for you to support your direct report’s professional development. Use this time to:
- Brainstorm or provide feedback on a direct report’s professional development plan
- Delegate a stretch assignment
- Check in on stretch assignment progress and help them reflect on what they’re learning
- Actively listen and ask open-ended questions to support growth
Demonstrate commitment and care
The 1:1 meeting is an opportunity to show care about your people personally and to get to know them as professionals and individuals. Occasionally rescheduling a 1:1 cannot be helped, but regularly canceling subtly signals that this time is less important to you.
Q: What if I’m not currently in a regular 1:1 rhythm with my team?
A: In Glad We Met: The Art and Science of 1:1 Meetings, Steven Rogelberg recommends resetting expectations with the whole team together. When doing so, explain:
- What is the purpose of 1:1s?
- Why do they matter to you as a leader and to your team/organization more broadly?
- What are your expectations for the agenda?
This way no one thinks they’re being singled out, expectations are clear, and it reduces the chance some team members get more access to you than others.
Q: What if my schedule is truly overloaded?
A: Consider adjusting your schedule before you cancel:
- Shorten 60 minutes to 45 or 30
- Move from weekly to every other week
- Proactively make a temporary adjustment. Sounds like:
Q4 is pretty hectic for the organization with deadlines, board meetings, budget calls, and holiday travel. Instead of meeting weekly for 60 minutes, I’m going to adjust us to meet 45 minutes every other week and set up office hours during which anyone on the team can book 20 minutes with me. We’ll restart our usual schedule in Q1 next year.
What’s one step you can take to recommit to high-quality 1:1s through the end of the year? Examples:
- Thoughtfully reset 1:1 schedule or agenda expectations
- Roll out an agenda template
- Ask more open-ended questions
|